r/Unexpected 4d ago

Wishing on One Wish Willow

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8.1k Upvotes

168 comments sorted by

u/post-explainer 4d ago edited 3d ago

This comment has been marked as safe. Upvoting/downvoting this comment will have no effect.


OP sent the following text as an explanation why their post fits here:


He tried to wish very carefully, but ended up as a cat.


Does this explanation fit this subreddit? Then upvote this comment, otherwise downvote it.

856

u/calm_thy_self 4d ago

r/catmemes but that would spoil the unexpected-ness.

196

u/Original_Bad_3416 4d ago

Interesting you can see the link through the spoiler block. Don’t think I’ve seen a link in a spoiler block

44

u/goose_gladwell 4d ago

Maybe you cant hide subreddits for some reason, nsfw maybe? Dont wanna accidentally open a link to [r/scatmemes](r/scatmemes) at work

37

u/Kuro-Tora-59 4d ago

For me its hidden, probably a reddit UI bug

4

u/HamsterKazam 4d ago

On my old phone I could just read through spoiler text. It wouldn't layer over it properly.

1

u/Fit_Cancel_8747 3d ago

That sounds frustrating. Reddit can be weird like that sometimes, hopefully it gets fixed soon.

2

u/Shady_Chaos 3d ago

I don't know if that's a real sub or not and I'm sure as hell not looking to find out

3

u/Amperesim 2d ago

It's a real sub bro

7

u/Disastrous_Lie_6698 3d ago

It's hidden for me

-2

u/Fr05t_B1t 3d ago

Maybe Reddit should’ve kept the formatting and stuff how it was instead of fucking it up and letting normies be able to format stuff.

8

u/QuaccDaddy 3d ago

Thoughtful of you to include a spoiler, but it's crazy to me that some people read through comments before finishing short videos and can't handle spoilers

535

u/Not_Tavato 4d ago

I expected him to end up in a nursing home.

137

u/TirithNampat 3d ago

I expected him to be a baby.

14

u/Glimmu 3d ago

That wouldn't be until he died? Well..

5

u/Soft_Theory_8209 1d ago

Going off the words in his wish, reincarnating as the heir to a vast fortune and possible humane foundation, mass job creator, and/or world benefiting thing without really needing to lift a finger sounds pretty solid.

24

u/eltee27 3d ago

I was so sure it would be a mental hospital.

-7

u/nanadoom 3d ago

Doctors, nurses, and orderlys aren't servants in any stretch of the word. Plus they aren't doing it because they want to

8

u/eltee27 3d ago

They are absolutely servants. Just not in the derogatory use of the word.

3

u/nanadoom 3d ago

No, they are care givers. Servants give you what you want and work for you. Care givers give you what you need, and they certainly don't work for you. It's more about the power balance and not work

2

u/FourDucksInAManSuit 3d ago

Until the end when he said he didn't want anyone's lives to be ruined, I thought it was going to be prison.

681

u/SlavCat09 4d ago

I mean I wouldn't mind being a housecat. Do nothing all day and get food and care for free.

259

u/Weelildragon 4d ago

No balls though.

353

u/Obaddies 4d ago

Take them. They've done nothing for me.

117

u/ndetermined 4d ago

My genitals have led me to places no mortal dare tread. Cast them away

3

u/MagMati55 1d ago

They only itched for me and made many situations much more awkward.

63

u/GNightP 4d ago

Me being trans and asexual:

https://giphy.com/gifs/6S2Q6LcnNd0hLsc9BD

7

u/owesome_apossum128 4d ago

That's what I came here to say, lol

2

u/FerreiraMatheus 3d ago

Holy moly, I think that's a first for me. It's now obviously, but trans and asexual is new for me.

15

u/Poly_Olly_Oxen_Free 3d ago

The lifespan nerf would be my only complaint.

10

u/Dark_halocraft 3d ago

Do nothing all day sounds miserable

3

u/SendMeF1Memes 3d ago

I would like to be those housecats which can leave the house whenever, but being a housecat to a nice family is nice too. Very chill, maybe boring but I could always annoy the slav-home owners.

2

u/thedogdundidit 3d ago

It's always been my dream life.

2

u/micromoses 4d ago

Yeah, but you’ll lose most of your sense of taste.

16

u/Crallise 4d ago

That's good since you'll have to bathe your nether regions with your tongue

9

u/ehe_tte_nandayo 3d ago

man how else have you guys been doing it

1

u/EndComprehensive8699 3d ago

You are welcome to be our housecat

247

u/IAmRules 4d ago

Money man, you just want money, that dude who wished for a billion dollars nailed with without even trying.

70

u/shyaznboi 3d ago

Still have no idea why he bothered to come up to their house exclaiming he got billion dollars when it literally happened in front of them just moments before

37

u/SnakeSlitherX 3d ago

Because Ian is a dumbass lmao

9

u/Fr05t_B1t 3d ago

BuT iT’s A mOnKeY’s PaW!

3

u/Soft_Theory_8209 1d ago

Using monkey paw logic, my best guesses for his catch are: IRS screwing him out of most of it, the cash itself being counterfeit, a bunch of family dying for your inheritance, instant inflation and/or an apocalypse making it useless, or actually storing that many paper bills safely without the government or gangs coming after you.

145

u/Gonzappa92 4d ago

I wish I could trade lives with my dog so bad😂

32

u/R0sewoodRibbon 4d ago

Honestly, same. Their biggest problem is probably deciding where to nap next.

23

u/DagothNereviar 4d ago

Wish granted! Now your owner is a dog in a humans body, has no idea how society works, loses their job and income, doesn't pay bills, is eventually sent to prison over massive amounts of debt and you're sent to the pound.

13

u/Gonzappa92 3d ago

Yeah on second thought I wouldn't make him suffer this hell.

2

u/IAmJohnSlow 1d ago

I think the best option would be to be a dog alongside your own dog lol

4

u/Sw0rDz 3d ago

I would pay you money if I could treat you like a dog.

6

u/PimpMyHide 4d ago

Get ready to lose some parts first buddy

https://giphy.com/gifs/98ZkINGNDjpbpkLzRx

2

u/Gonzappa92 3d ago

I let him keep his, hopefully he'd do the same😂

2

u/GlorifiedBurito 3d ago

But your dog is always missing you when you leave.

74

u/NaturalBornLucker 4d ago

He forgot to add a clause against neutering

18

u/Friendly-Back3099 4d ago

I mean tbf, losing the balls is probably for the better

2

u/NaturalBornLucker 4d ago

But what about licking them? It's a main attraction of being a cat!

0

u/wakeupwill 4d ago

Would fall under the "no harming" clause.

7

u/NaturalBornLucker 4d ago

I'm no lawyer but when we neutered (or sterilized, dunno correct word) our cat, we didn't think of it as harming her.

27

u/CatRockShoe 4d ago

I was actually just thinking the other day that I wouldn't mind at all being someone's pet cat

2

u/Thin-Nerve6367 2d ago

Ah but then you gotta lick your ass clean.

No thank you

1

u/APiousCultist 3h ago

Spend all day sleeping, die by age 15. Can only express life's problems as loud meows. There are some downside.

24

u/OuttHouseMouse 4d ago

Tries calling the help line on back of box:

"Hi yes, can i help you?" "meow meow meow, meowmeowmeow meow"

2

u/Artzebub 3d ago

They get that a lot. And wof, wof, wof, and help! I'm a human trapped in a parrot!

15

u/blindseersarasti 3d ago

Honestly the one wish willow isn’t really ever shown to be a monkeys paw, the main wish was just kind obviously a terrible wish

1

u/ut1nam 8h ago

Yeah. We see two other people use it and they seem perfectly happy with their wish. I don’t think OP got that. It’s just giving you what you want as explicitly outlined in your wish and your intent.

0

u/Soft_Theory_8209 1d ago

Granted, we only see one other wish, and it is possible they just seemingly didn’t give him a drawback because they forgot to or didn’t think it was importantly enough to include/contribute to the story. Although, yes, many have speculated he just made a terrible, overly selfish wish and was punished for it.

On that note, while they don’t seem to have plans for it, the concept of the one wish willows has basically given the creators a gift wrapped potential film series exploring different wishes and their catches.

26

u/ridisberg 4d ago

I’ll take it

9

u/Deivedux 4d ago

Just wish for a billion shares of some ETF, like All-World or S&P500. A good enough head start into financial independence.

21

u/Indercarnive 3d ago

Just wish for a billion dollars ( or more). It literally happens in the movie with no adverse effects. The wish isn't some monkey paw or genie trying to twist. Bear's wish turns out bad because it's a fundamentally bad wish.

4

u/arrkaydee 3d ago

To be fair, we don't actually know if it has any adverse effects because of what happens immediately after he makes the wish. We also have no context as to whether or not it's a monkey's paw because we don't see any other wishes.

For all we know, the money was taken from a bunch of charities and now a ton of people are going to die because they no longer have the help they need.

3

u/Thin-Nerve6367 2d ago

Plus there's no guarantee the IRS won't be on his ass.

I'd just make a wish that says "The next three lottery numbers I choose are winners"

Boom, done. Win the lottery once and then only get another one - or two - tickets if I absolutely need the money

2

u/arrkaydee 2d ago

Unfortunately, you need 7 winning numbers to win the jackpot and you only have 3, so you've won $10.

Gotta be more careful with wording your wish!

1

u/Thin-Nerve6367 1d ago

😆

The next 3 lottery tickets I hold in my hands are winners

I think that's good

2

u/arrkaydee 1d ago

A cashier hands you your receipt but accidentally also gives you three winning lottery tickets someone else just cashed in. They're of no use to you.

Alternatively, you win $30. Your tickets were winners, but not jackpot winners.

3

u/Thin-Nerve6367 1d ago

😆 fair fair

1

u/SlobberyFrog 1d ago

We know the guy from store made a wish tho no ? Didn't he wish to have the store he owned in the movie or smth?

1

u/arrkaydee 1d ago

I don't think he ever says what his wish was, so it could have also gone wrong, but not catastrophically so. I could be wrong, though.

2

u/Icura71 4d ago

The shares would have to be stolen from someone. Or a single share split into a billion shares...

3

u/Omnom_Omnath 4d ago

stealing isnt legal. just add some numbers to their digital bank account, no harm no foul. its all a grand-societal illusion anyhow.

3

u/Deivedux 3d ago

Steal them from the richest 0.1%, they won't even notice that amount is gone.

1

u/shyaznboi 3d ago

SPY has 1.05 billion shares. If you monopolize almost all of it, people will just use a different ETF. Making your billion shares worthless

7

u/Wazula23 4d ago

I think being a well-cared for housepet might be the peak of consciousness. So I call it a total win.

11

u/_HIST 4d ago

Lmao that's good

9

u/GainsayRT 3d ago

''I wish the richest man on earth, whoever that may be at the time, would want to donate 1 million dollars to me each month, out off the kindness of their heart''

3

u/choicebethedeathofme 2d ago

* because you have the most horrific disease and he feels bad

5

u/trashcanjenga 3d ago

This was pretty expected honestly.

7

u/nussbrot 4d ago

Was expecting for him to become a dog....close enough

3

u/domine18 4d ago

SCORE!!!!!!!!! Sounds heavenly

9

u/Beaufort_The_Cat 4d ago

lol honestly my first move with one of these would be to hire a team of lawyers to make it foolproof and tell them to write themselves in to the wish to get paid

2

u/Fr05t_B1t 3d ago

No no, they will be satisfied with the work that they did so much so, that compensation is not necessary.

3

u/ray10k 4d ago

Reminds me of a song.

Everybody wants to be a cat~

3

u/SpartArticus 3d ago

Literally just say i wish to legally have a trillion usd in my bank account that is valid and can be used and doesn't cause the economy to change in any way because of this

8

u/ArguablyMe 4d ago

So cute.

2

u/Styrlok 4d ago

Pretty expected closer to the middle, but it's still funny :)

2

u/100YearsWaiting2Shit 4d ago

I've been thinking about this since I saw the movie. The best course of action is to wish for a magical object. It's shown it can make money appear out of thin air so I won't ever make a wish that would involve changing my being. Even wishing for more confidence has me terrified how it'll fuck my brain up. So I'd just wish for some object to benefit my quality of life like a bullshit detector or a never ending heal all medicine with no side effects in a forever refilling bottle

3

u/TheRealRiceball 3d ago

Is the One Wish Willow established to be a monkey's paw situation? From what i remember of the movie it seemed pretty generous, just that Bear made a really dumb wish

2

u/100YearsWaiting2Shit 3d ago

Less about it being a monkey's paw and more about me not trusting myself and being indecisive so my indecisiveness might mess with the quality of the wish

2

u/Soft_Theory_8209 1d ago edited 1d ago

Obligatory: I wish I knew what to wish for, which becomes hilarious with it being ONE wish (unless you later pull off the mother of all manipulations on someone).

1

u/100YearsWaiting2Shit 1d ago

I have genuinely thought of the strategy of buying two and giving it to a family member saying to wish that I knew what to wish for

1

u/thatguy2585 2d ago

The wish is neutral, it’s the wording that made it go bad

2

u/Affectionate-Boot-12 4d ago

Just wish for all of superman’s powers without any weaknesses. Done!

3

u/Fr05t_B1t 3d ago

Well his weakness doesn’t exist in reality

1

u/Soft_Theory_8209 1d ago

Red suns… debatably magic going off the OWW.

1

u/Fr05t_B1t 1d ago

Co…co…COMMIE!!!! /j

1

u/veritasmahwa 3d ago

Constantly caring for everything to move around seems exauhsting. I dont wanna live in a world that feel like cardboard. Maybe something less powerful but still overpower in real. First i thought of Goku but then i notice i still need to train myself. Then i thought of Mob(Mob psyco 100) but then i notice i may not be able to control it properly. Who to pick? Yujiro hanma?

2

u/Furebel 3d ago

Wishing for money making machine will make you be jailed for fraudulent money printing. Wish for a machine that without any material or energetic input with effortless press of a button will instantly generate fully edible, healthy to eat and moderately tasty chicken nuggets with exact atomic structure as regular man-made chicken nuggets. The machine will require no downtime, maintenance or cooldown and it will be fully waterproof. One press equals one chicken nugget.

No way to worry about food will already cut most of your issues. Because the device is infinite food with no hooks (i hope) you can sell chicken nuggets too. Why moderately tasty tho? Because if you have the best chicken nuggies, you might draw too much attention, and if you eat it yourself over and over, other food might get dull, and you can still spice it up to your liking. Still, you can sell them for dirt cheap, and it will still be a huge return to you for the simple reason of how insanely lot of them you can produce for zero cost. This solves joblessness and homelessness issues. The only thing you should be afraid of is thieves, but if you play your cards right, you will be able to quickly afford security systems to protect your chicken nuggies machine and yourself. You could surely ask for more, but each wish and its modifier comes with a huge risk, so its better to come up with one straightforward wish, describe it as best as you can, and prevent catches.

2

u/Prigeonn 3d ago

Thought he would end up in a vegetative state

1

u/AilBalT04_2 4d ago

I'll take that

1

u/thin_orange_line 4d ago

I would wish for infinite wishes with no negative impacts

1

u/Party-Heron5660 3d ago

It’s built to being a cat within ten seconds

1

u/ChuckDeBongo 3d ago

I thought it was going to transform back as a child so his mum and dad could look after him all over again…

1

u/The_Black_kaiser7 3d ago

I was thinking mental institution...

1

u/leorising88 3d ago

This is exactly what I expected lol

1

u/deeps1x 3d ago

My guess was dog.

1

u/siul1979 3d ago

I was expecting he would be a dog, but yeah, a cat is close to what I expected.

1

u/warsremix 3d ago

But that ending directly went against his wish??

1

u/volatilezengirl 3d ago

i see this as an absolute win

1

u/tnecnivx 3d ago

That’s like 40 wishes, not one. It’s a one wish willow

1

u/YoungDiscord 3d ago

"Please grant the wish I'm about to say without any negative drawbacks"

1

u/Joe_Spazz 3d ago

My grandfather used to say he wished he would be reincarnated as an American dog.

1

u/Mike0621 3d ago

this apparently improves his life, since that was part of his wish

1

u/Joxsund 3d ago

couodve just wished for a billion dollars. like the MOVIE!

1

u/DamageMaximo 3d ago

it ruined his life, his wish was ignored

1

u/mvw2 3d ago

Nailed it!

1

u/BoBoBearDev 3d ago

I am glad this isn't the video end too soon sub.

1

u/Rogueshadow9087 3d ago

Soo... he should have just wished to be the legal recipient of legal dividend paying stocks, where the dividend income amounted to about the median houshold income.

1

u/astor24 3d ago

Just watched Obsession last night, spot on perfect wish 🤣

1

u/zirky 3d ago

i see this as an absolute win

1

u/ChairLegofTruth--WnT 3d ago

Well loved housecat is the nat 20 of reincarnation rolls

1

u/TheReblogBandit 3d ago

I'm fine with it. Please make me a cat

1

u/SaurikSI 3d ago

I’d just wish my life to be perfect. Nothing that could make me sad could happen, so indirectly it would help others as well.

1

u/Conscious-Struggle45 3d ago

I wish for everything I want to come true in the way I intend it to come true and only if I actually want it and without any permanent consequences I can't undo.

1

u/pecanmarshmallow 3d ago

Wouldn't prison be a good fit too?

1

u/SpinachSpinosaurus 3d ago

until he cracked it I thought he was going to be a child again, living with his parents...... And when He said "do not ruin somebody's life with that wish", it became somewhat clear in hindsight that...this wasn't what was going to happen.

1

u/wrapperNo1 3d ago

I don't like cats, but I'd take this wish!

1

u/nahunk 3d ago

I saw that coming at least midway through, sorry

1

u/Ser_Daniel_The_1st 3d ago

Sometimes when making wishes you can’t account for everything which will inevitably fuck you up.

1

u/theGamingdutchman 3d ago

I'd wish to restart my life as the best version of myself, which would include taking away all the weird annoying or harmful quirks my body has. To basically be me 2.0, to have access to my current memories if relevant or if I tried but to be otherwise unbothered by my current attempt at life.

To still be (mostly) the same person in my core and to mostly still meet the same people. But for it all to be the BEST i could've been. To be a driven, ambitious and happy person.

1

u/MrJakuubix 3d ago

Cool joke, but the point of the movie was that the One Wish Willow is NOT a monkey's paw that purposefully fucks you over

1

u/FluffytheReaper 3d ago

Yet he has to lick his own ass

1

u/Interesting-Air8924 2d ago

Zero rent, free food still dead inside.

1

u/MelangeBot 2d ago

Amateur. What you really want is a wish-audit.

1

u/RudeAwakening38 2d ago

This guy's a prompt engineer

1

u/Giggling_Unicorns 2d ago

whats with the cringy music added to the original video?

1

u/kildaver 1d ago

Had five business days to see that ending coming. 🤣

1

u/Gin4Gingers 1d ago

Fun fact! The one wish willow is not a monkeys paw. It gives you exactly what your wish is, exactly how you expect it to be. The only reason it went so bad in the movie is because bear was mentally unstable and he truly wanted her to be that obsessed but didn't expect the consequences. Hence his medicine cabinet and also how the wish for a billion dollars didn't come with a downside because that guy wasn't mentally unstable and really just wanted a billion dollars

1

u/_Beempathic 1d ago

Not bad, but you will die soon of kidney failure.

1

u/WitchesTeat 1d ago

I called it as soon as he finished the servant bit and I was not disappointed

Always specify it not ruin your life, either, and that you enjoy the outcome with a mentally and emotionally sound and stable mind

1

u/desmorck 19h ago

Honestly that does not look that bad! My pets are spoil

1

u/Starhunt3r 17h ago

The moment he said servants I knew

1

u/CRAKEN000 16h ago

Fucking monkey paw wishing dude.

1

u/VortexLord 4h ago

If the person wish for infinite money what is the monkey paw outcome? Other people receive less salary or-?

-2

u/EcstaticActionAtTen 4d ago

Ppl hate ai with a passion but we came to the Internet to escape the FCC but everything is censored for monetization and stuff like unalive is normalized